225 South Fulton Street · Suite #1

Coins, jewelry, bullion, watches, and estate pieces.

A family-run Ithaca shop for buying, selling, and no-obligation evaluations, with a focus on clear categories and careful in-person service.

Ithaca Coins and Jewelry storefront on South Fulton Street
30+ years Serving the Ithaca area
Family-run Personal buying and selling help
No-obligation Evaluations for current market value

Bring in what you have

A clearer path for selling coins, jewelry, bullion, diamonds, and watches.

Gather the item, keep any boxes or paperwork with it, call ahead for timing, and bring it to the South Fulton shop for an in-person look.

Display case with paper currency and coin sets
Gold coins and bullion displayed in a retail case

Rare coins and bullion

Buying and selling rare coins, paper money, silver, gold, and bullion pieces.

Gold jewelry gathered on a white surface

Jewelry and diamonds

New and estate pieces, with evaluations for items customers are considering selling.

Watches arranged in display trays

Watches and small services

For watch-related help, call first to confirm timing and fit.

Rows of collectible coins in holders

Evaluation rhythm

Simple enough for first-timers, precise enough for collectors.

  1. Call to confirm shop hours before bringing valuable items.
  2. Keep coins, watches, jewelry, and documents grouped by type.
  3. Ask for a no-obligation evaluation and next-step options.